First, let me say welcome! We're glad to have you. You might consider posting also in the "Members Only" area; some people never look at the public forums (I generally don't, but this caught my eye).
Now, take a deep breath! Paper is a great choice, so the trick is to just start. It doesn't have to be perfect because you can always fine tune later. Just start.
Next, go to the Connect home page and look for "Paper Planner" materials. There is a great webinar (recent) that will walk you though what needs to be there. Use the search box or click on the tab labeled "Audio and Video Library" and look under webinars until you find it. Also look at the tab labeled "Set up Guides". You'll find one there for paper planners.
And take it one step at a time. Really getting GTD is a process...enjoy the process!
I am the Party