I just used a quality, zip up, 8.5/11 inch binder. I bought dividers with pouches and called them the usual: In, Calendar, Actions, Projects, Project Support, reference, horizons. Used my official Brother labeller to make the divider labels.
I used heavy stock paper from Office Depot, and got the little stick-on Post It index tabs for the individual lists under Action. (computer, home, work, waiting for, brain dead, etc.) Errands go on Outlook which synchs to Android (Galaxy 4).
worked great. Binder is a bit big and heavy and I wonder if I should have used the smaller size, but it was nice to be able to put a full sized sheet of paper in it. For example, I printed my own project planning worksheets with Outcome, Principles, Support (Outlook folder, Windows folder, paper, etc) as a checklist, Brainstorming, Organizing, and next actions.
Am now migrating to Evernote and enjoying the process but paper is the way to go when learning! And for many it remains the way to go.
Email: Outlook and Gmail, PC and Android
Lists: Paper organizer and Android for errands
Wondering about Evernote!