Figured out why I wasn't able to see the completed tasks. When I created the new custom view, I copied the "Active Tasks by Action GTD" view. I added the filters as Ken and Pam suggested. But my Active Tasks by Action GTD view already had the filters of "complete does not exist and complete = no" to begin with.
I removed those 2 filters and added the new steps and now it works exactly as I wanted.
Thanks a ton for the help.