I am not advocating one of the other as being most efficient, optimal, etc. but realizing that is how I am built. I am a strong visual. I know that if I ever put something in a drawer I will never see it again unless either A. I have a checklist (written or mental) which says "look in this drawer" every day or B. I'm looking for widget A and I remember it is in the drawer.
I don't think this is very different from anyone else. What's the alternative? What I think David was saying and what I said is that neither the all-in or all-out style is necessarily effective or ineffective.